Doctors training notes

Thyroxine and osteoporosis

I am 54, and I have an underactive thyroid for which I take thyroxine. In 1989, I unfortunately allowed myself to be talked into taking HRT. The one reason that persuaded me was the protection it supposedly gave against osteoporosis.

I thought it would be a good idea to have a bone scan to see how much my bones had been protected. The results were very worrying. My bone density was below normal in both my spine and hip. I went to a lab for tests which showed up magnesium and zinc deficiencies, but an osteoporosis profile showed no lack of calcium!

You cannot imagine my disappointment when I had my second scan yesterday showing a 10 per cent drop in my spine and slightly less in my hip.

I am now told this is all due to thyroxine, which I have been taking for 20 years!

When it was found I had an underactive thyroid back in my thirties, my consultant said I would be on thyroxine for the rest of my life, but he assured me there were no side effects from this drug. It was the only drug that didn't have any! Twenty years on, the story has changed, as it normally does.

I feel it is important for patients to seek other ways of stimulating the thyroid into normal action, rather than resorting to thyroxine, and ending up with my problem. P B, Sunningdale, Berks...........

See WDDTY vol 6 no 7 for information about the inaccuracies of thyroid testing. We'll be covering natural methods of stimulating the thyroid in an upcoming issue, so please keep reading.

Related WDDTY Content

The bone scan - A fractured picture

This is one of the main tools for detecting osteoporosis and other bone changes, especially in the lower spine, hip, forearm and heel.

Low bone density

Q I ve recently been diag nosed with osteopenia My doctor is keen to start me on raloxifene but I m worried about potential side effects Could you...

Bone density level not a key factor in fractures

The decrease in bone density that accompanies aging is only a small factor in the greatly increased risk of hip fracture in older life, researchers ha...

Bone density improved by following your advice bone density improved

Two years ago, I had a bone densitometry test, which showed osteoporosis in the left hip. My doctor prescribed Fosamax and a calcium supplement. Tha...

Thyroxine and osteoporosis

Perhaps the biggest question question mark over long term thyroxine is its ability to cause osteoporosis. One study of long term thyroxine users show...

Low bone density or other risk factors?

It is generally assumed that low bone density indicates fracture risk. However, dense bones may not necessarily be sufficient to prevent hip fracture...