Family matters

The real problem with beta-carotene

I read with interest your Updates (WDDTY, vol 9, no 12) about the findings of beta-carotene and cancer, which I am already familiar with, but feel to be misleading and poor science.

From my understanding of this issue, this adverse result is likely to be caused by the use of beta-carotene. When taken in higher doses than other carotenes, beta-carotene will compete with them for receptor sites.

The result can be a deficiency of the other carotenes, and this may well be the problem, as these are also important nutrients.

This also explains why foods rich in beta-carotenes (which are also rich in other carotenes) do not carry the same risks. Francesca Naish, Natural Fertility Management, Woollahra, New South Wales.....

Related WDDTY Content

Beta-carotene is good for veins

Atherosclerosis where fats narrow the main arteries, sometimes leading to a heart attack can be helped by taking beta-carotene, new research has disco...

Beta-carotene: now the good news

Despite recent adverse publicity, beta-carotene does provide an effective safeguard against lung cancer, new research has found. ...

Beta carotene supplements may cause cancer

Very high doses of beta carotene supplements may be cancer causing, as two earlier, and controversial studies had concluded. Diets that are rich in fo...

Beta carotene: studies must take a wider view

Your leader in the September newsletter "Of Strokes and Smokers" about the beta carotene studies (WDDTY vol 7 no 6) bought up some important issues re...

Carotene blocks cancer fighters

Beta-carotene supplements, believed to be cancer preventatives, paradoxically could be surpressing other cancer fighters in the body, especially in so...

Carotene trial 'political'

The recent decision of the American National Cancer Institute to stop a trial which was testing beta carotene as a cure for smoking induced lung cance...