Alternative Treatments

Natural remedies that may be dangerous

These natural remedies may be good for some of us, but menopausal women should take them with caution.

Natural progesterone: It is so called because it is derived from yams – although it is still processed in laboratories first. It’s supplied as a rub-on cream, and its advocates argue that it is chemically identical to the progesterone produced by the body. As such, they say it is safe, unlike the artificially produced progestogens used in the pill or in HRT (hormone replacement therapy). The problem is that progesterone is seen as the ‘good’ hormone, but this fails to understand the delicate balance in the body. Estrogens increase antibody production, but progesterone decreases it. As such, there is growing evidence that progesterone may, on its own, be carcinogenic.

Soy: Women who eat soy to avoid breast cancer can develop the very disease they are trying to prevent. Several studies have suggested that soy may cause breast cancer cells to proliferate. It also blocks the uptake of zinc and magnesium.

Don quai and ginseng: Although both these herbs are two of the most popular remedies to treat menopausal symptoms, several studies have shown that they also encourage the proliferation of breast cancer cells.

Black cohosh: This is one of the best natural supplements for treating menopausal symptoms, but it shouldn’t be taken for more than six months at one time. It should also be avoided by anyone with a history of breast cancer in the family.

Herbs: Plant estrogens can have as powerful an effect as synthetic ones, so don’t substitute and think its automatically the safer option. Studies have shown that some herbs – and especially soy, liquorice, red clover, thyme, turmeric, hops and verbena – act as tumour promoters.

Back to How You Beat the Menopause

Related WDDTY Content

Menopausal symptoms - More plant remedies for the menopause

* Gamma-oryzanol. This naturally occurring mixture of the plant chemicals sterols and ferulic acid esters has proved effective for reducing menopausal...

Menopausal symptoms

Q My life is being made hell by hot flushes and night sweats. I am 50 years old and reluctant to take HRT. And now all the herbs have been discredited...

GUIDE TO THE MENOPAUSE

This 68-page booklet guides you through the menopause minefield, looking at HRT, “natural” progesterone, hysterectomies and the dangers and liklihood...

Alternative treatments of menopausal symptoms

Several doctors have reported success in treating the menopause without drugs. Nutritional medicine experts Drs Stephen Davies and Alan Stewart recom...

Getting rid of menopausal symptoms naturally

Eat a variety of foods and increase your intake of plant foods. This increases the number of different phytochemicals you ingest and decreases the lik...

Breast cancer: Menopause herb spreads tumours

Women with breast cancer may be spreading the disease if they are also taking a herb for menopausal hot flushes.