Click here to read about some of the people we've helped.  We're here to help you, too. Get four essential health reports by joining our e-news community.

Four FREE health reports for you

Register now for our vital and insightful health updates, and get four free health reports to help you live more healthily.

First Name:Email:


Family matters

Breast cancer screening - false positive results

Dear WDDTY

I write to thank you for the the article on breast cancer (Vol 3 No 10). I became interested in the subject about 12 years ago when a colleague became seriously ill with this disease and showed me the burnmarks that radiation treatment had made on her skin. Just about this time there was launched in Edinburgh a breast screening campaign which involved thousands of women from this city. The campaign was to run for eight years with volunteers having a mammogram every other year. For nearly all these years the director was Dr Maureen M Roberts, who to begin with was a perhaps over enthusiastic believer that mammography was the answer to longer life for breast cancer sufferers.

As you may know, Dr Roberts had the courage to write in the British Medical Journal that the trials had failed to prove anything. She even admitted that there had been a number of false positive results. Shortly after this Dr Roberts herself died of breast cancer. S S, Edinburgh......



WDDTY Blog Speak

Breast Cancer screening confusion - I am 63 and recently had my first breast mammogram. I was therefore very disturbed when I read the article "The Disease Women Fear Most" in the Januar...

Breast screening: - The mystery of the disappearing tumours - Mammogram screening is generally agreed to be best practice for all women over the age of 40. It's supposed to be soon enough to detect early signs o...

Breast cancer screening challenged - Annual mammograms do not reduce breast cancer deaths, say Canadian researchers. ...

Breast cancer screening doesn’t prevent deaths - Mammographic screening has been used for years to supposedly detect the early stages of breast cancer. But a committee of US cancer experts - the Phys...

Breast screening: no benefit - While doctors consider stepping up breast cancer screening, new data has revealed a regularly screened woman who develops cancer is no better off than...

Breast screening: costly errors - Treating women who have had a false positive mammography screening (detecting cancer where there is none) is a third of the cost of providing screenin...

The mammogram myth - How all our massive screening efforts for breast cancer can cause the very disease they are intended to detect. ...

Mammography - The hard truths behind the screen - As breast cancer rates continue to spiral upward (to 185,000 women in the US and 28,000 women in the UK every year), the pressure is on for women, par...