Click here to read about some of the people we've helped.  We're here to help you, too. Get four essential health reports by joining our e-news community.

Four FREE health reports for you

Register now for our vital and insightful health updates, and get four free health reports to help you live more healthily.

First Name:Email:


Doctors training notes

What can i do about my breast cysts?

I recently had a run-in with my local hospital when they insisted that I have a mammogram before they would scan the cysts in my breasts or aspirate them, or do anything else. As I don’t believe in unnecessary mammograms - I think they are probably cancer-inducing and hurt - I declined, came back home and referred to your book What Doctors Don’t Tell You to see if I was mad. There is a lot of information there, but a lot of it refers to the early and mid-1990s. I wondered if there were any updates or anything that would change that viewpoint.

Incidentally, I am bedevilled with large, painful cysts and no one - no GP or any specialist in several London hospitals has any understanding of them. Hospitals don’t want to aspirate them as they are not cancer. They are painful and I wish I could find out more.

Yes, there are a few articles around about coffee, tea and chocolate, but I don’t see them backed by research or any bigger understanding of the issue.

In the past, I have given up all these foods and dairy products for up to three months, but it makes no difference. - DB, London

WDDTY replies: The conclusions about mammograms in What Doctors Don’t Tell You the book are in fact strengthened by current research. Some countries are questioning the wisdom of using them at all for screening as they not only show no survival benefit, but are a positive danger. Although a recent study favours mammograms for younger women, the weight of evidence continues to show no survival benefit for healthy women. Indeed, the high-dose radiation may contribute to cancer. Mammograms may be useful once you’ve found a suspicious lump, but a safer alternative in the right hands is ultrasound scanning, which doesn’t expose you to ionising radiation.

As for benign breast cysts, check out our Alternatives column in WDDTY vol 6 no 11, which contains many proven remedies such as evening primrose oil.

WDDTY Blog Speak

Breast cysts: - Lots of advice for the reader last time who has started to develop breast cysts. The Bowen Technique is a good place to start, says one reader, who h...

Mammograms - Q:I am 47. My doctor is pressing me to have mammograms every other year. What evidence is there that it can help prevent cancer? M S, Hitchin. ...

The mammogram myth - How all our massive screening efforts for breast cancer can cause the very disease they are intended to detect. ...

Knowing your local hospital services - A little preparation goes a long way. Needless to say, the better the hospital and quality of care, the better your outcome and chances of surviving y...

Breast cysts: - While many readers who wrote in about their experiences with breast cysts linked it to menopause, it is possible that the condition could be related t...

Mammograms: - Could they have helped kylie? - In the week that pop star Kylie Minogue announced that she has breast cancer, a new study from her homeland Australia remains dubious that earlier mam...

Breast lumps after mammograms - In October 1991 my doctor sent me hospital for a mammogram. (I am 57.) ...

The informed mammogram - Make sure your doctor knows that just because you don't want a mammogram, it doesn't mean you don't want your breasts checked. You can tell your docto...