Click here to read about some of the people we've helped.  We're here to help you, too. Get four essential health reports by joining our e-news community.

Four FREE health reports for you

Register now for our vital and insightful health updates, and get four free health reports to help you live more healthily.

First Name:Email:


Screening for lung cancer doesn't reduce death

Regular screening of individuals at risk of lung cancer may not reduce death from the disease.

This unexpected finding came via a long term follow up study (20.5 years) of the Mayo Lung Project. The original study, conducted between 1971 and 1983, was criticised for arriving at this same conclusion. While it was thought that an extended follow up might reveal a reduction in mortality from regular screening, this has not proven to be the case.

The reason is thought to be due to what is known as 'overdiagnosis bias'. Regular screening may be revealing anomalies in the lung which have no significance in terms of patient lifespan.

However, once detected, the patient with such an anomaly is put on an 'at risk' list. The fact that patients generally do not die from such anomalies has long been taken as proof that screening works.

Study director Pamela Marcus, from the National Cancer Institute in Bethesda, Maryland, noted that the dangers of overdiagnosis in other cancers have already been recognised. Such over detection of cancers, especially given the new screening technologies available, may lead to unnecessary treatments that do more harm than good (J Natl Cancer Inst, 2000; 92: 1308-16).

WDDTY Blog Speak

Lung cancer - A reader’s friend has been recently diagnosed with lung cancer. She has been told it is inoperable and is just starting chemotherapy. Do readers know...

Lung cancer: - The drugs that don't work - Lung cancer patients are usually prescribed either Tarceva (erlotinib) or Iressa (glefitinib). Doctors will probably tell the unfortunate patient tha...

Eat your veggies to prevent lung cancer - Isothiocyanates valuable nutrients found in cruciferous vegetables may help to prevent lung cancer, say Chinese researchers. ...

Carotene trial 'political' - The recent decision of the American National Cancer Institute to stop a trial which was testing beta carotene as a cure for smoking induced lung cance...

Diabetes: ‘Safe’ drug linked to lung cancer - Pfizer withdrew its diabetes drug Exubera last October because of lagging sales. At the time the decision seemed strange. The drug, an inhaled form...

Can Vitamin C be used as a Cancer therapy? - The US National Cancer Institute is taking a hard look at the effects of vitamin C on the body, particularly its alleged ability to treat cancer. ......

Do screening programmes influence Cancer mortality? - Doctors tend to visualize many diseases as a little army that starts small, enlisting, at most, a soldier or two. If they can locate and flush out th...

Cancer: when it isn’t a killer - Dcis: precancer, benign cancer or what? - The cancer establishment was recently rocked to its core when Professor Michael Baum, an eminent and well-respected breast surgeon and researcher, cla...